The Science Fiction Review Books God Emperor of Dune by Frank Herbert

God Emperor of Dune by Frank Herbert

God Emperor of Dune Book Cover

Frank Herbert goes in a completely new direction with his fourth book in the Dune series, God Emperor of Dune. This novel has quite a different feel than the first three. The setting takes place 3500 years after the ending of Children of Dune. Dune’s ecological transformation is complete except for a small patch of desert. As a result of the transformation, the sandworms (and the supply of new spice) died off. Leto has almost completely transformed into a sandworm, and has taken over as leader of the galaxy. He’s been working on his “Golden Path” all this time while sitting on the last big hoard of spice.

Aside from the lack of new spice, there are a few other developments. The Guild Navigators are working with Ix to develop a way to safely travel through space without spice. Leto is aware of this plot, but does not seem to be worried. Also, Leto has continually resurrected the Idaho ghola to act as the leader of his female army, the Fish Speakers. One of the youngest in Leto’s breeding program, Siona, has rebelled and stole his secret personal journals. She sends these to the Ixians hoping to find some type of weakness so that she can kill Leto. To complicate matters, Leto has ordered one of his top Fish Speaker guards, Nayla, to act as a double agent, obeying Siona even if she is ordered to attack him. This is all set up within the first 50 pages or so.

One of the main things that annoyed me with this book is the constant ramblings of Leto which don’t make much sense. Before each chapter there is a section from the stolen journals which has some sort of wise saying about the workings of the world, human nature, war, or economics. Some of the stuff makes sense, but most of it seems a bit out there. Leto makes it clear early on that Siona is to be tested to see if he can explain the Golden Path to her.

I lost count of the references to the Golden Path in conversations between Leto and his servant Moneo Atreides, father of Siona. With only 50 pages or so I got frustrated because I still wasn’t sure what the Golden Path was. It turned out that Herbert doesn’t reveal this until the last few pages. The first three quarters of the book were a fairly tedious read. The last part I finished in just a few hours, where before I could only read a few chapters before having to take a break.

There is some seriously messed up stuff that happens toward the end of the book that I won’t go into because of spoilers. Trust me, you’ll know it when and if you read it. Now is a good time for me to take a bit of a break from the Dune books. I’m sure I will read the rest sometime in the future, but right now I have several other books that I’ve been anxious to get to.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you are a human * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Post

Isaac Asimov – The Last Question and The Last AnswerIsaac Asimov – The Last Question and The Last Answer

I’ve said here many times that Isaac Asimov is my favorite author. It wasn’t until a few years ago that I read “The Last Question,” Asimov’s favorite short story written by himself. Last night I stumbled across a story called “The Last Answer.” At first I thought, “hey, I’ve read this before,” then did a double-take. It was “Answer,” not “Question.” This story focused on the afterlife instead of entropy. They are both good stories, however I agree with Asimov in his opinion that “The Last Question” is better. I highly suggest reading them both, but I’m not sure what order to recommend. I’ll list the links in order of publication, so you decide. Read both stories before looking at the comments on either one, because they are filled with spoilers.

“The Last Question” – Isaac Asimov (1956)

“The Last Answer” – Isaac Asimov (1980)

Svaha by Charles de LintSvaha by Charles de Lint

Cover of Svaha by Charles de Lint
Cover art © Tor Books / Charles de Lint — used under fair use for the purpose of review.

As I sat down to write this review, I realized I couldn’t remember the last time I read an entire physical book. Since 2018, all my novel reading has been on a Kindle Paperwhite. Before that, I used a Kindle Fire but still alternated with physical books. Reading on the Fire was always a bit of a hassle because of the glare. The Paperwhite’s e-paper display is in a completely different league. I like it so much that when I revisited the Foundation novels a few years ago, I borrowed the ebooks from my local library even though I already had the physical copies on my shelf. One nice perk of the Paperwhite is that it’s easier to read while eating because I can flip pages with my knuckle.

Recently I wanted to disconnect from electronics before bed. The best way seemed to be grabbing something from my bookshelf that I hadn’t read yet and didn’t already have digitally. That’s when I noticed Svaha by Charles de Lint. I vaguely remembered seeing a recommendation for it years ago and picking up a copy through Book Mooch, a site where people trade books they’re done with. I’m pretty sure it’s been sitting unread for over ten years.

When I pulled Svaha off the shelf, I could barely remember how or why I got it. The cover, showing a Native American man with a wolf, didn’t ring any bells, and the back-cover description didn’t sound like my usual genre. Most of my reading leans toward science fiction and, more recently, fantasy. Still, I decided to trust my past self and give it a shot.

The story takes place in Canada sometime after 2094. Without spoiling too much, the setup is that in the 1990s a Native American named Daniel Hollow Horn became a music superstar and used his fortune to educate and empower his people. Over time they became world leaders in science, technology, and law, eventually surpassing the rest of the world. After a period of war, they withdrew into self-contained “Enclaves,” kind of like Wakanda from Black Panther, except everyone knows where they are. They managed to protect themselves from the pollution and fallout left behind while the rest of the world fell apart.

(more…)

Isaac Asimov’s Robots and Aliens Book 1: Changeling by Stephen LeighIsaac Asimov’s Robots and Aliens Book 1: Changeling by Stephen Leigh

Robots and Aliens Volume 1 book cover

One thing I like about this book is there is a nice eight page synopsis of the whole Robot City series. Even after just reading the series, it was a nice refresher for the events leading up to Robots and Aliens. This new series involves Asimov’s challenge to the authors to describe what might happen if robots encountered an alien species. How would they treat them? How would the Three Laws apply?

I particularly enjoyed this first book because it addresses one of the main questions I had regarding the Three Laws of Robotics. What does the key phrase “human being” actually mean? Throughout Asimov’s books and it is explained that the laws aren’t as simple as the English translation. They are complicated sets of positronic potentials that govern every action of a robot.

In Changeling, Stephen Leigh describes a robot model that is given a very simple definition of “intelligent life form” as an equivalent. This idea seems to work very well in this book and after several chapters we see how this experiment intersects with the Robot City plotlines. Also, we get to see Derec use the powers he was given to control Robot City. One thing that did bug me a little bit was how little of the main plotlines was advanced.